At the end of 2009, I set up a poll at the Tenners about the journey to publication for some of this year’s debut novelists. Here are the questions and answers:
1. What came first, agent or publisher offer?
- Agent: 82%
- Publisher: 18%
2. How did you find your agent?
- Slush pile query: 58%
- Met at a conference: 14%
- Referral: 11%
- Query, with publishing offer in hand: 6%
- I don’t have an agent: 6%
- Professional connections: 3%
- Other: 2%
3. How many agents did you query before getting an offer:
- 1-10: 54%
- 11-20: 15%
- 21-30: 10%
- 31-40: 4%
- 41+: 17%
4. Did you have multiple agent offers:
- No: 58%
- Yes, 1-3: 38%
- Yes, 4+: 4%
5. From the time you/your agent began submission, how long did it take your book to sell?
- Less than a month: 47%
- 1-6 months: 36%
- 6-12 months: 11%
- Over 1 year: 6%
6. Did you have multiple publishing offers?
- No: 51%
- Yes, 1-3: 35%
- Yes, 4+: 14%
7. Is yours a multi-book deal?
- No: 47%
- Yes, 2 books: 42%
- Yes, 3+ books: 11%
8. How many books did you write (now stuffed in a drawer somewhere) before the one that sold?
- None, this is my first: 18%
- 1: 31%
- 2: 26%
- 3: 7%
- 4: 11%
- 5+: 7%
9. How many writing conferences did you attend prior to selling your book?
- None: 29%
- 1-5: 44%
- 6-10: 24%
- 11+: 3%
10. How long, including pre-sale edits, did it take you to write your debut novel?
- Less than 1 year: 39%
- 1-2 years: 24%
- 2-3 years: 9%
- 3-4 years: 13%
- 4-5 years: 2%
- 5+ years: 13%
11. Have you met your editor and/or agent?
- I have met both of them: 31%
- I’ve met my agent, but not editor: 13%
- I’ve met my editor, but not agent: 11%
- I’ve never met either of them: 45%
12. How old are you?
- Under 20: 0%
- 20-30: 25%
- 31-40: 51%
- 41-50: 22%
- 51+: 2%
13. What is your work status (post-book sale)?
- I write full-time, no other job: 29%
- I have a part-time job: 15%
- I have a full-time job: 25%
- I am a stay-at-home parent: 31%
14. Which best describes your debut novel?
- YA Contemporary: 35%
- YA Paranormal: 22%
- MG Contemporary: 15%
- YA Fantasy: 11%
- MG Fantasy: 7%
- YA Historical: 3%
- MG Historical: 3%
- YA Sci-Fi: 3%
- MG Sci-Fi: 0%
- MG Paranormal: 0%
15. Prior to selling your debut novel, had you been published?
- No: 47%
- Yes, short fiction: 17%
- Yes, “other” (only include work for which you were paid): 17%
- Yes, non-fiction articles: 14%
- Yes, non-fiction book: 5%
- Yes, adult novel: 0%
16. How long have you wanted to be a writer?
- Less than 1 year: 2%
- 1-5 years: 4%
- 6-10 years: 7%
- 10+ years: 16%
- Or, my whole life and I’m so incredibly amazed and thankful that this is actually really, truly happening: 71%
For some of my thoughts and take-aways, visit the Tenners.
Disclaimer: I am a writer, not a professional pollster or statistician. I stink at math. The 55 respondents don’t include all Tenners and certainly not all debut novelists and not all 55 responded to every question. Most did, but the 3 without agents didn’t answer the agent questions, obvz. You could probably draw a lot of conclusions from this info - some different than mine – including that this is a very small sample size and self-selecting since we’re all kids’ writers who joined the same online community. I just thought this was interesting. I’m kind of a geek like that.

January 12th, 2010 - 9:48 am
Fantastic post!
January 13th, 2010 - 8:41 am
This is awesome! You wouldn’t mind if we Elevensies did this too, would you? I’d be interested to see if the patterns are similar.
Yeah, I’m a former statistician. *hangs head in shame* Can’t help myself.
January 13th, 2010 - 1:01 pm
I’d love it if you guys repeated the poll – it’d be really interesting to see difference/similarities. Isn’t it funny how many writers are closet numbers geeks?
January 23rd, 2010 - 12:43 pm
Very interesting! Your disclaimer cracks me up
February 3rd, 2010 - 3:03 am
[...] Selling Your First Children’s Novel: A Poll [...]
June 4th, 2010 - 11:42 pm
Hi Jen, I was Googling and found your blog. Love this poll and just Tweeted about it. I’m on submission via my agent, and so I’m hanging onto question #5!! The Mark looks Awesome. Am Looking it up now.